NFL MVP Race Sparks Controversy in 2025

This season in Buffalo, football fans were treated to one of the most contentious MVP races in recent memory. Josh Allen has been named the NFL Most Valuable Player for the 2024 season, narrowly beating out Lamar Jackson. This tight contest has raised some eyebrows, especially since Jackson was named a first-team All-Pro by the same voting panel that decided the MVP award.

It’s rare to see such a close call, and many believe it to be a first in NFL history. One voter, Jim Miller, who is a former player and current radio host, surprised many by placing Jackson fourth on his ballot. Miller chose Allen for the top spot, followed by Saquon Barkley, Joe Burrow, and then Jackson. For context, this seems outrageous to many, considering Jackson’s performance and impact throughout the season.

Looking at the voting results, Allen garnered 27 first-place votes compared to Jackson’s 22. The tally shows that while both players were recognized for their contributions, the weight of their votes varied significantly. Only three other players received votes in the MVP race, with Barkley and Burrow lagging behind. The voting breakdown highlights that Allen was the clear front-runner for the MVP title, but with Jackson receiving such strong support, it’s puzzling how some voters ranked him lower.

Although Miller’s vote did not directly cost Jackson the MVP, the voting discrepancies raise questions about the decision-making process among voters. It remains a topic of discussion among fans and analysts alike, pointing to the complexity of how MVP titles are awarded and the varying opinions of those casting ballots.

As the NFL continues its season, the debates about the MVP race and what defines “value” in the league are sure to persist, keeping the excitement alive for fans and pundits looking ahead to next year’s competition.